Honestly, this has not made it easier to see my health at a glance, it has made it harder. Where on the old/current HUD, it was universal that “more red to the left”=bad and “less red to the right”=good, now it’s completely mishmashed. Red bar further to the left on my shields is “bad” whereas red bar further to the left on my hull is “good.” I really really don’t need to see a variable-sized HP bar to tell the difference between my shields/armour/hull at a glance, but having them all going the same consistent direction is crucial to that. Please change this back before the full release…
If you really need to make a distinction between how much shields/armour/hull there is, then simply make the bar be split into more “chunks” (more bars) for more HP (i.e. a small amount of armour might only have the bar split into 3 chunks, but a large amount of armour would be split into 40 chunks). That’d solve the “problem” you’re trying to fix, without ■■■■■■■ up the consistency of a static visual bar length.
HP diminishes counterclockwise. It’s not that difficult to understand that. It’s a circular display, left and right are irrelevant. In fact, it was exactly the same way on the old HUD, with the difference that the old HUD had a bigger radius, thus it didn’t display as close to full circle as the new one.
Meridan Night, that only works for passive-tanked ships, where each layer gets damaged in sequence.
This is a common mistake to make, FC also did not realize it, but EVE also has the ability to repair (upper) layers. Active armor and shield repairs exist!
This means the new HUD can in fact have red left of white, which makes readabilty of the new HUD ambiguous and unclear.
I wish FC realizes sooner rather than later that active repaired ships exist, because the new HUD is awful for those. Not only is it unclear which part of red is meant for which layer, the ‘main layer’ of active ships is completely ignored because active ships do not stack raw hitpoints but use resistances and repairs.
An active ship now sees their most important layer take a far smaller part of the HUD, possibly even the smallest fraction of all.
It’s awful.
Completely and utterly agree with what he said. Couldn’t have said it better and with a graphic example.