The New HUD Is a Textbook Example of Incompetence

Hi! I’m sure most of the new HUD will have been fixed by the time I finish writing this post, but that’s not the point. I’ve been playing this game for over 20 years. I’ve seen it all, and that gives me the right to speak up. I’ve also held leadership positions in fields that let me give objective, meaningful feedback on development, so I know what I’m talking about.

So, let’s start with question number one.

What does moving the buttons I’m used to from left to right, and from right to left, on the HUD do for me as a player? From bottom to top, and from top to bottom? The answer: NOTHING. Nothing except inconvenience and problems.
Is your development team familiar with the rules of UX design? One of the most important ones is: don’t touch anything users have gotten used to. Are you paying your developers for this? Paying for pointless, unnecessary work? Okay. That’s your right.

Question number two.

You talked about the new interface a long time ago, but… you never got around to testing it? Okay. The players will do that work? Honestly, that’s not a bad approach from a management standpoint (and I’m not being sarcastic). But how do you miss such obvious errors, in both the design and the functionality of the new HUD? Did anyone there even turn it on? Use it? How am I supposed to click on the ship’s speed bar in the new HUD to select the speed I want? Why isn’t the HUD designed in one consistent graphic style? The clash is jarring and makes the whole thing harder to use. Why has everything become wider, clumsier, and so inconvenient? Why are there all these unnecessary sounds when interacting with the HUD?

Important: Are you even aware that your target audience is people aged 35 to 45 who have presbyopia and struggle to make out small details on a monitor? Why are the capacitor segments even smaller and clunkier than before? Why is everything so tiny and awkward? Why can’t the capacitor just be one big dynamic bar, or simply a number?

Question number three.

I don’t want this to sound like an ad, but… why is everything here subjectively better, and why was it all made by just one person? How did he manage it alone when you couldn’t do it with entire departments?

Apologies for the single big collage: as a new forum user, I’m limited to one image per post, so I packed in the clearest examples.

I’m very glad my subscription runs out in early December.

6 Likes

lol you really are stuck in 2004 huh?