Hulk hold could use a buff

All tests were done with the same Orca boosting at the same skill levels with the exact same abyssal rolled miners (nothing crazy, just an extra 3m/s), and a Highwall 5% implant. The point was to show the top end problem that exists.

The Hulk’s last ore hold balance pass was in 2021, when it went from 8500 to 11,500. Mining criticals were added in 2025. And i think criticals are the problem that makes the hold feel too small.

Ship m3/s Normal
Cycle m3
Critical
Cycle M3
Mining Hold After
Critical
Reserve
Time to fill,
Normal (s)
Time to fill,
1 Critical (s)
Hulk 125 777 3115 11500 5270 42 17
Mackinaw 94 718 2678 44300 38944 414 (7min) 385 (6.5 min)
Skiff 75 629 2346 18500 13808 184 (3min) 152 (2.5m)

“What is ‘after critical reserve’?” Both mining lasers can crit. Even if you stagger them you have less than 7 seconds (assuming you staggered them perfectly) to react before the next beam might crit. So you need to leave enough space in your ore bay to handle a double-crit event. After Critical Reserve shows how large the mining hold is when leaving this free room to handle a double-crit is.

42 seconds to fill the mining hold with only normal cycles is a little short. It takes me 60 seconds to stand up, walk to the bathroom, pee, and walk back. It’s not a far walk, but I also don’t feel like running. That’s a comfortable speed to do things. I feel like ‘pee time’ is a good minimum. I can set my marauder guns to fire for 1 minute and I’m locked in place by a bastion cycle. Why can I not get the same 60 second window while mining?

But criticals break that. If you get a single critical, normal cycles will fill your hulk’s hold in just 17 seconds. And keep in mind, all these numbers are with an Orca. A rorqual would be even worse, as the buffs are even stronger there. That said, people who live in null have a completely different set of mining issues, so, yeah.

I’m aware compression is instant and a single button press. What I’m saying is I want to be able to get up and pee without not having to risk filling my ore hold!

I understand why the Hulk’s hold is as small as it is. If you made it the size of the mackinaw, for example, multiboxers could run fleets of 10-50 hulks and strip mine fields because the long fill time would make that viable. As it stands, the mackinaw is the multiboxer’s tool of choice for that specific reason. It requires less APM (actions per minute) compared to a hulk. And make no mistake, multiboxers are the thing mining is balanced around. It has to be.

I don’t know that the skiff or mack need to change if the hulk changes. 6.5 minutes to fill with a single critical is plenty reasonable. Even 2.5 is reasonable, given how strong of a tank you get with it. And you pay for that with a 40% hit to mining rate.

So what do I propose / ask for?

I ask that the 1-critical time to fill go from 17 seconds to 60 seconds.

60 = (X - 3115*3) / 125 →
60 = (X - 9345) / 125 →
60 * 125 = X - 9345 →
7500 = X - 9345 →
7500 + 9345 = X
X = 16,845

Round up and make some room for drone mining results and call it 17k, or round up to 16.9k. Either way is good. That will allow the hulk to mine for 60 seconds, getting one critical (which is as many as is common in 60 seconds).

I know this will have ripple effects. But I also don’t feel like it’s unreasonable.

Edit:
I went ahead and made a quick and dirty rorqual in pyfa to get numbers for the hulk in that case:

179m3/s with a max rorqual boosting. 2541 critical, so a critical cycle is 2541 + 777 = 3318 m3.
3318 * 3 = 9954
60 * 179 = 10740
Thus, 20,694 is the minimum hulk hold size to last 1 minute, with 1 critical, with a max rorqual boosting.

Edit2: formatting
Edit3: I missed a 0 in the Mack’s hold capacity.

Why did the Mackinaw go WAY from Mining Hold to After Critical Reserve when the other two went slightly down?

Shouldn’t the number for Mining Hold for the Mackinaw be 31,500?


With that out of the way, If you have an Orca, you should see about using it for ore storage when flying a Hulk.

I keep telling people that if a Hulk’s lasers are on, the pilot is NOT afk. The hold requires constant maintenance.

I don’t think that decreasing the ore yield across all ships is the solution. I throw my ore into the Orca. Pee on your own time.

I had a typo. There should have been one more 0. I fixed the post. My bad. 44,300 is the correct mining hold value for the mack.

I did not propose nerfing anyone’s mining rate. I personally use mobile depots to hold the compressed ore so I don’t have to sit next to the orca. But it has the same effect. I believe you’ve failed to understand what I am trying to convey.

Were these not your words asking for a longer delay between crits?

That’s not what that means. I’m asking for the hold to expand so that 1 critical takes up less space in the hold, and thus, the endurance of the hold’s capacity under incoming ore is increased.

I’m not asking for the faucet to let water into the cup slower. I’m asking for the cup to be bigger.

My mistake. But dumping the ore (or ice) into the Orca is better than compression. It doesn’t matter if your Hulk is full of ore or compressed ore. A full hold is a full hold.

Oh wow… The Ship Tree is wrong. It is 44,296.9. I had to go buy one to check. I was planning on buying one anyway.

The Hulk does not need a buff.

The Hulk is the best and most popular Exhumer of the three. All I ever see used are Hulks Hulks Hulks, and my own Exhumers are Hulks.

Yes, the Hulk has a designed downside of sacrificing ore hold for superior mining yield, which is an intended drawback which could let you choose one of the other Exhumers if you find it problematic.

With remote compression from Orcas and Porpoises this downside however has become almost non-existent and irrelevant, which to me suggests the Hulk is in need of a nerf to bring it in line with the other two Exhumers.

Luckily the introduction of mining crits meant that a Hulk is a bit more likely to waste some of this efficiency due to randomness of when ore comes in, which I think brings it almost in line with the other Exhumers instead of far ahead.

The Hulk is fine and does not need any changes.

If anything, it should get it’s hold reduced even further to make up for the fact that unlike when the Hulk was designed you can now compress the ore while in space.

And if a small ore hold does not let you take a bathroom break? Then choose:

  • take a break from mining. Nothing bad happens if you stop mining for 30 seconds. (And you’re less likely to lose a Hulk if you dock in that time too.)
  • use a Mackinaw with superior ore hold size so you can take all the breaks you want

Your options are there. The only problem I see here is that you want to have the best yield of the Hulk but want to have the convenience of an ore hold too.

You want to have your cake and eat it too.

The Hulk is most definitely not in need of a buff.