it was an example. If the defenders have 25 people as you said, they can bring 20 BS + 5 Logi. If you allow Marauders they could bring 20 Marauders + 5 Recons. Nothing more, nothing less. I don’t see the situation for small gangs that try to rob ESS improving if Marauders can get in there.
Depends. Marauders can usually project a LOT more DPS over a LOT more range. Means, against 20 T1 BS you might have a chance to at least escape if you pull enough distance quickly enough to warp. Against 20 Marauders you just get melted in seconds, even if you are already at 80km when they enter.
And that was a good change. Now disallow Bastion Module and I have no problems with Marauders entering the ESS again. They’d lose a lot of their huge range-projection potential but can still fight like a normal Battleship.
Marauders are beasts. If you were to field one Marauder from each faction against five of the best fit non-Marauder battleships in New Eden, the long-range missiles and guns along with any other bonuses to NOS / Neuts, Stasis, etc., would shred any attempt to get close. While the long range had a ship tied down, the close range would move in and annihilate the first ship, then the DPS ramps up the next target, then ramps up again. By the third loss, you will be asking yourself, why didn’t we align to a point and start AB’ing when the first ship went down?
Before this change every ESS fight and comp centered on the Vargur. How does it survive a Vargur? If it doesn’t, it’s not viable. I mostly stopped doing ESS stuff, not because I couldn’t deal with the triple ancil Vargur that was always there, but because the fights got so samey. You had to kite and you had to bring ewar to stop the Vargur from shooting.
ESS fights are so much better and so much more diverse now.
I think you may have misunderstood. You don’t necessarily need to kite to kill a Marauder—Remote Sensor Dampeners are a very powerful piece of equipment, and even though Marauders can’t enter the ESS, I still carry them. You can look at my Marauder kill records from a year ago; you’ll see that killing a Marauder doesn’t require many people. With just 5 people, I can kill any Marauder.