I’m not going to answer because I feel the best approach, if CCP is ever to allow capitals into hisec, is more nuanced. (If you can, you may want to make a third poll entry for “other”.)
See my thread on the matter here.
Short version: allow carriers and dreads only to use gates into 0.5, 0.6, 0.7 systems, but make them suspect by doing so unless their personal standing with the empire faction owning the system is high enough. 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0 systems would still be off limits to all capital ships. No cynos in hisec (although you can still jump out), no titans, supers, or rorqs in hisec, and I’m on the fence with FAXs.
Keep in mind, I’m still not sold on the idea. But I think it’s the most workable proposal I’ve seen, and it fits neatly with the whole ongoing Triglavian/Drifter Invasion theme.