You are so blatantly and criminally naive, it’s funny. Have you heard of the concept of deleting contracts when you go offline? Or account sharing? Or corp contracts with other people logging in to keep watching? Please, if you do not know how these things work stop telling people how you think they work.
With citadels, almost nothing is legit. And not even a clean history make a citadel contract legit, as an example of a formerly “trusted” citadel near Jita demonstrated.
And whether my definition of scam would not hold up in court is completely irrelevant to the matter. For illustration purposes, I suggest you check the contract histories of Johnnyy Boy or Bitter Old Veteran or FionaFirelfy. All characters I have blocked and who are guaranteed access scammers. I am not throwing out any “legit” citadel contractors because there are nearly any. So far, I only know 3 people who do legit citadel courier contracts. Nearly 100, though, who are scammers.
That list is there but it also only works retroactively. Only once someone had to fail a citadel contract or someone finds a closed citadel with an active contract, people land on the black list. And it is almost impossible to get on white list because every entry there is a potential compromising citadel to the legitimacy and reliability of the white list. Not to mention that sometimes places and people land on the black list because some of their corp mates screw over their own corp without them immediately noticing. There are truly marvelous stories happening in the haulers community.