Suggestion: Allow Players to Opt Out of PvP Across the Entire EVE Online Universe

then go play those games.

1 Like

“easy targets” are bread and butter of this game. if the target is “hard”, you miscalculated or misjudged the situation.

1 Like

Lots of "Maybe"s.

Maybe you don’t understand the situation here: If people would be allowed to grind resources in absolute safety, an endless legion of alts would farm said resources in absolute safety 24/7, dropping the value of said resources down to nearly zero. Which in return means, those PvP player who actually risk ships and suffer losses can’t even make money any more by mining or farming LPs or whatever… because whatever they earn is worthless.

It works in other games, because “death” there is mostly meaningless, you simply respawn, along with most of your stuff. And where it isn’t (like Diablo or PoE Hardcore leagues), the economy is restricted to those leagues as well, you can’t throw a 1000 Zod Runes into the HC market just because you have them in your single-player stash (duped -_-).

1 Like

You can already opt out of PvP, stay docked.

1 Like

Imagine all the ishtar farmers or crab runners opting out of pvp… lol?

1 Like

I understand your argument, and I agree that simply allowing a player to disable PvP while continuing to operate under the same economic conditions would create an imbalance.

But that’s precisely why my proposal isn’t just about adding a button to toggle PvP on or off. It would require reworking the rules governing economic participation and interactions between players.

For example, players who choose not to participate in PvP could face transportation restrictions, cargo limits, or other conditions preventing them from using this option to move billions of ISK worth of goods without risk. Likewise, they shouldn’t be allowed to participate in wars, territorial disputes, or provide strategic advantages to players involved in those conflicts.

The example you presented highlights a genuine balancing issue, but it doesn’t necessarily mean an alternative system would be impossible to develop. It means such a system would need to be designed with those consequences in mind.

I’m also not suggesting that EVE should stop being a PvP game. I’m questioning whether mandatory PvP participation needs to remain the only way to experience a universe that offers so many other activities.

I recognize that this would require significant changes and might not be feasible within the game’s current structure. But I believe there’s a difference between identifying the challenges of a proposal and claiming that it simply cannot work.

I get the impression that you’re responding to how EVE currently works rather than the proposal I’ve presented. I know PvP is present throughout the game, but that’s precisely what I’m suggesting we reconsider, with economic and strategic restrictions to prevent imbalances. Repeating that EVE is a PvP-based game doesn’t invalidate my suggestions; it simply describes how the game currently works. If the question is whether the proposal is viable, we should discuss what specific problems would remain even with these limitations, rather than simply stating that the game has always worked this way.

You seem to believe that the only valid way to play EVE is the one that matches your personal preferences. But EVE is a much bigger universe than just PvP: exploration, mining, industry, trading, and logistics are all part of the experience too. Nobody is proposing to take away your right to engage in PvP, but rather to discuss alternatives for players who prefer other activities. The game wasn’t made exclusively for you, and your way of playing doesn’t have to be the only possible one. If you disagree with the proposal, that’s fine, but telling other players to uninstall the game isn’t an argument.

PvE players have just as much right to enjoy everything the game has to offer as PvP fanatics do, without having to face restrictions.

Do they tho?

For a game that places so much value on player freedom, it’s contradictory that everyone is forced to participate in PvP or face trade restrictions that confine them to what essentially feels like a trial or tutorial version of the game. Freedom should also mean being able to choose how to enjoy this universe. Not everyone plays EVE because they enjoy killing other players and stealing their belongings. Some simply want to explore, mine, manufacture, trade, and enjoy everything New Eden has to offer. Your preference for PvP is perfectly valid, but it shouldn’t be the only acceptable way to experience the game.

But shouldn’t it tho?

Seems to me like you should have to PVP to play EVE, even if it’s only a little bit.

You seem to misunderstand what I wrote. Read it again. And then try to understand the consequences. If you make players invincible, they just rival for the same anomalies, the same belts, the same hacking sites with players who actually risk their ship. It’s a hilarious idea. You don’t have the slightest clue how a market works and how people would abuse it.

Did you actually read and understand what I proposed regarding limitations and less severe restrictions? It seems like you’re only arguing in favor of maintaining the current system, ignoring the fact that my proposal would involve reworking some of the game’s existing mechanics.

There are several possible ways to prevent the economic imbalances you mentioned: a separate economy, limited influence on the main market, dedicated trading stations, new ores exclusively for PvE activities, materials used to manufacture lower-tier equipment, or trading restrictions. These are just a few initial ideas that could be developed and refined.

I’m not claiming these solutions would be perfect. I’m simply pointing out that there are alternatives worth exploring. A constructive brainstorming discussion would be far more interesting than rejecting every possible change simply because EVE has always worked a certain way.

Exordium already imposes significant limitations on players compared to the rest of New Eden. My suggestion is precisely to find a less restrictive balance that offers more opportunities for players who prefer PvE, without compromising the economy or the experience of those who participate in PvP.

I’m not asking for the game to be simplified or for risk to disappear for everyone. I’m proposing different ways to participate in this universe, each with its own rules and proportionate consequences. For those who participate in PvP, nothing would change, but I believe this could particularly benefit new players without necessarily harming veterans.

You keep criticizing issues I’ve already acknowledged and suggested possible solutions for. At no point did I propose making players invincible within the current economy. I’m talking about reworking game mechanics, introducing restrictions, and exploring alternative economic models. If you disagree, point out specific problems with those alternatives instead of simply repeating criticisms I’ve already addressed.

Yes, that’s why I didn’t suggest removing the system entirely, just offering an alternative.

No, and that’s not an argument, nor does it add anything to the discussion.

If you offer an alternative, as you suggest, some people would be able to play the game with no PVP, that’s not good.

Essentially your idea is terrible, and proof that you are not only a coward, but you lack respect for any EVE players.

Please go away and stop bothering us.

separate economy, pvp opt out. breaking game core concepts to do exactly what? Farm pixels in total safety, then what? You sound like a complete noob who wanna rewrite a 25y old game because he doesn’t like pvp. go play a different game, there’s plenty of those.

You raise some valid concerns about EVE’s economy, and I agree that my original proposal didn’t fully address the consequences of allowing players to opt out of PvP without economic restrictions.

Initially, I argued that PvE players shouldn’t have to accept reduced rewards or lose access to resources and activities. However, after considering the points raised in this discussion, I recognize that some limitations and penalties would be necessary to prevent exploitation and maintain economic balance.

That doesn’t mean PvE players should be confined to Exordium or treated as if they’re playing a trial version of EVE.

There are several alternatives worth exploring:

  • Separate or partially isolated markets, with dedicated trading stations and restrictions on transferring goods between PvE and PvP economies.

  • Resource and reward adjustments, allowing PvE players to mine and manufacture profitably, but without gaining the same economic advantages as players who accept PvP risks.

  • Cargo and transportation restrictions, preventing protected players from safely transporting billions of ISK worth of valuable goods through dangerous systems.

  • Manufacturing limitations, such as PvE-specific materials used to produce certain categories of equipment.

  • Strategic restrictions, preventing PvE-protected players from participating in sovereignty conflicts, wars, military operations, or providing unfair advantages to PvP participants.

These are preliminary ideas, not a complete economic model. Issues involving alternate accounts, market manipulation, and indirect transfers of wealth would also need to be addressed.

I also understand your point about ship destruction being essential to EVE’s economy. A protected PvE system could reduce demand for ships and equipment, which is another reason why economic separation, production limitations, and alternative resource consumption mechanisms deserve consideration.

What I’m reconsidering is the extent of the restrictions, not the fundamental purpose of my proposal.

I still believe players should have the option to explore New Eden, mine, manufacture, trade, and participate in PvE activities without being forced into direct combat against other players. But I now recognize that this freedom would need to come with proportionate economic and strategic trade-offs.

The goal shouldn’t be to give PvE players all the benefits of New Eden without any risks or consequences. It should be to offer a meaningful alternative experience without undermining the existing PvP economy.

I’m not claiming this would be easy or that my suggestions solve every problem. I’m proposing that we explore whether such a system could be designed.

There’s a significant difference between acknowledging that EVE’s current mechanics wouldn’t support unrestricted PvE immunity and concluding that no alternative system could ever work.