Overall, I actually quite like the new HUD, but I think several functional considerations may have been overlooked during its design. Much of what follows has already been raised by others, but I think it’s worth reinforcing those points.
Audio
Personally, I really like the new sounds. They give me quite strong KOTOR vibes, which is certainly not a bad thing. However, I can completely understand how others might find them intrusive or irritating over extended periods of gameplay. Having dedicated volume controls or the ability to disable HUD sounds would be a welcome addition.
Form over function
Visually, I really love the new module buttons, iconography, and readout styling. However, the overall design feels heavily weighted towards aesthetics rather than functionality.
There is a considerable amount of wasted space throughout the HUD, particularly around the capacitor, module racks, and utility buttons. Despite occupying this space, some of the most important information is now smaller and less prominent than before.
The HUD is arguably the most important functional element of the EVE interface. Information density, readability, accessibility, and ease of interaction should take precedence over artistic presentation, particularly given the complexity of EVE’s gameplay.
Utility buttons
The current “Display Utility Buttons” option disables both the left and right groups simultaneously. These should, at the very least, be independently configurable.
Personally, I interact with the buttons on the left far more frequently, whereas the functionality associated with the buttons on the right tends to remain enabled for extended periods. Naturally, this will vary depending on the player and their activities, which is precisely why independent visibility settings would be beneficial.
Separating these buttons across either side of the HUD also seems unnecessarily wasteful. It increases the overall footprint and fragments important HUD elements without providing any obvious functional benefit.
Consolidating these elements into a more logical and compact arrangement would improve accessibility whilst reducing the overall HUD footprint.
Capacitor and spatial efficiency
The capacitor depletion indicator could potentially be implemented as a thin circular indicator around the capacitor itself. This would still allow for the central capacitor display to be enlarged, making better use of the currently wasted space whilst retaining the same information.
More generally, I echo the concerns others have raised regarding overall wasted space, particularly when important readouts such as velocity have become so small in comparison. There seems to be a disproportionate allocation of space to decorative elements, negative space, and functional information.
This becomes particularly noticeable when multiboxing, where being able to quickly interpret ship status across multiple clients is incredibly important.
-
Reduce unnecessary spacing between HUD elements.
-
Improve the size, prominence, and readability of important information.
-
Improve text contrast against bright environmental backgrounds.
-
Consolidate utility buttons into a more logical and spatially efficient arrangement.
-
Make better use of the available space within the capacitor display.
These are fundamental usability considerations that should ideally be reflected in the default design, rather than requiring players to configure their way around them.
I don’t necessarily think the new HUD needs to be reverted. There are several aspects of it that I genuinely like, and I think it has the potential to be a considerable improvement over the previous iteration.
However, a HUD is fundamentally a functional interface, not an artistic centrepiece. Ideally, the aesthetics should complement its functionality, rather than dictate it.
Illustrative example
I’ve attached a rough mock-up to illustrate the general direction I have in mind: a more compact, accessible, and spatially efficient HUD that retains the new visual identity whilst prioritising functionality.
Please forgive the crude execution, as I am neither an artist nor a UI designer. The specific positioning of the icons would naturally require further consideration regarding their functionality, frequency of use, and logical grouping. However, I hope it demonstrates how much of the currently wasted space could be reclaimed whilst improving the prominence and accessibility of important HUD elements.