Obligatory make the Orca better thread

Long time miner/industrialist first time Orca pilot

Finally decided to get an Orca. Have been training the skill set out to max for the best boosts etc.
Took a LONG time , several months of training to get the skills up to 4-5(taking all to 5 cause of my OCD)

Dropped a couple Bil on the hull / fittings / fuel / boost ammo etc etc etc.

I do use it for boosting for my corp mates as CCP/FC intends it to be used for.

Here is the thing though.
I have played solo for a while, recently joined a corp again.
As a solo miner I know the maths, don’t need to see it or have it hammered into chat again. My Mackinaw and Hulk can FAR out-mine the Orca in pure throughput without being boosted and WAAAY out-mine it with boosting. Even the mining barges can out-do it with skilling.

I invested a LOT of skill training time / Event Skill-Point rewards / Daily mission Skill-Point rewards / Air Achievement reward / Event training booster consumables / redoing my attributes to maximize the training reduction time so that I could not just sit in the Orca but could Actually fly it and be effective. Not going to lie, I love it
Especially helping out my corp members and helping them make that space money is great. Everyone is very appreciative when an Orca pilot fires up the indy core and hits the belts.

Now this statement.
I do not Multi-box. Eve is a game not a job for me. Im not fielding an Orca and a fleet of MB-Hulks to follow me around.
There is NO real draw to a solo player to work towards getting into and using the Orca OTHER than being able to sit Semi-AFK in a belt and let your drones slowly chew at rocks/ice.

I’m not saying CCP/FC should make the Orca a mining monster.
Just give it a slight bump so that solo players would also want to own their very own mining surfboard and could actually legitimately mine in the thing and feel like their months of training and isk investment have been worth it. Maybe even see a nice return on such as large long running time and isk sink.

Allow the orca (and rorq) to field 1-2 extra mining drones as a hull bonus
Allow the orca to field 2 ice mining drones as a hull bonus

Small bump, not game breaking, would not make the orca over powered , but would help anyone who is solo flying one of these space mining behemoths feel like their investment is sort of worth it.

2 (roughly) 2 billion isk and multiple month training investment should feel like it is worth sitting in even if I am not boosting a group of people.

I will get my roughly 250 million mackinaw out to solo mine before I undock the Orca and that shouldnt be the decision. I should want to get into my large investment ship and take it out.

They aren’t mining behemoths.

Is that really so hard to understand?

They are not designed to mine stuff. And they are not meant to be played “solo”.
They are meant to command, store, compress and haul large amounts of mining resources.

Who cares? Enough people do. And giving the Orca more Drone Mining Capabilties would just make that afk-Orca problem worse.

So thanks but no thanks.

6 Likes

Behemoth - Something large.. The Orca is a big boat. Used here as word play.

So with your view point.
If someone is a solo industrial player in EVE (a lot of people are) they should just not want to fly a better indy/mining ship than a Mack/Hulk?

Just get to that point and stop.

They skill out and payout for a new bigger ship like the Orca and then never use it because their smaller ship is a better option. Stay in the small ship solo-player and never advance into something better.

If they use the newer bigger cooler looking ship their ROI is horrible as a solo eve gamer.

Heck even with mine, boosting like Im doing.
Im helping out a newbro corp by providing boosts for the up-coming new players to mine/earn isk etc.
Im footing the bill for Fuel and Boost-Munitions. Im risking a multibillion investment when I undock.

I tell everyone that Donations are not needed/required but appreciated because Im trying to be a good person and help the new guys grow and get more hulls to fly.

My ROI is low my risk is high. Why not give the Orca a small bump of a couple extra drones to at least let fleet boosters and any solo-indy player get a bit more ROI in our huge time/isk investment?
how would this break the game in your opinion?

Like you said a lot of people Multi-box, its their game they can play it like they want. They are still going to field a fleet of Hulks to strip the ore and ice belts dry in minutes. The orca is just a boost-machine to them. It would not break the game to allow it to mine a bit more on its own.

Heck, If nothing else it would give the Gank-squads a challenge to go out and try to bring down a high EHP Boat as there would be more out there.

He doesn’t mine himself any more. He buys large amounts of resources and produces and sells Items made from the BPOs he has accumulated.

And besides that, the game is a massive multiplayer online game. It isn’t made for “solo players”. You can of course do that, but then live with the limitations. For sure the devs shouldn’t make changes to please “the solo guy” that would have negative impact on the whole multiplayer environment (yes, people afk-multibox dozens of Orcas for hours and hours).

So: The best “Mining” ship you can fly “solo” is an Exhumer. Period. Live with it. If you want more, join a group.

2 Likes

The Orca is not a mining ship. It’s a command ship. It’s not going to outperform ships that were built to mine. That’s just the hard reality of it as you just learned. Even if your drone skills are maxed out and your Orca is filled to the rim with drone modules, you’re still going to suck at mining.

Here’s a safety tip- Orcas that are fitted with drone modules are very easy to gank. If you don’t protect that investment, you’re going to lose a lot of money. You’re a command ship pilot. Once you set foot inside an Orca, you’re no longer a miner. You need to fit the Orca with lots and lots of shields.

The hard truth: Piloting an Orca is BORING!!!

If you don’t have a mining ship on a second account parked right next to you, you’re going to get bored.

So? Orcas aren’t mining behemoths. they’re Command Behemoths

2 Likes

OK so then to the Rorqual with this same line of thinking you have.

Why did CCP/FC make it able to field a better mining drone with the Excavator class of drone?
Why even give the mining drone boosts to the Porp/Orca/Rorq from the Industrial core?
If the line of thinking is “Its a boost boat/command hull” why even give it a bump to mining drone output.
Why create excavator drones for the Rorqual / Heck just let the Orca field the Excavator drones now that I think about that.

Just give it command bonuses and regular mining drones and put it on the field.

Because even though this is an MMO and you can play with others, some people do not want to do that. If you haven’t noticed there are a lot of Elitest A-Holes that play this game.
Its their money they can play solo too.

People who do not multi-box and are still using it as a command ship like Im doing are still playing the game , we are still sitting there watching our screen and we would like the same satisfaction as the Hulk miner that Im boosting in throughput and compression and able to tear through belts and get an even bigger ROI on their small investment.

I want to feel like I can effectively mine in my Orca too. I would like a bit of a higher ROI because I did spend allllll the time and the higher cost to buy this thing than someone else who did not.

I think people confuse this with “I want my Orca to out-mine an exhumer”.
NOPE
The exhumer is a ship that specializes in its job.. Ripping roids apart.

And before you quote it and throw it back
The Indy Command ships specialize in boosts (I get it, not dumb to that role for this ship) I knew that when I bought it. I wanted to help my newbro corp grow so I took the initiative to do this.
Would not change the fact that I did this and bought the ship. Its still great.

For fun in this game (yes eve is still a game.) It would be fun to see a bit of return on my investment without having to demand that anyone I boost give me isk. I want to see my big ol boat mine at a rate that makes me want to field it when I play in my spare time (stupid adult responsibilities)

you know.. For fun game play.. “THATS NOT ALLOWED IN EVE” Ive heard it before.

This is my opinion and view point.
That is your opinion and view point.

I see both as valid.

CCP likes null sec and it’s a capital ship. Take your pick. I don’t care.

CCP released a statement a long time ago stating that they did not want the Orca to outperform Exhumers. They stated that. Their exact words were pretty close to, “We do not want to see miners do a mad dash for the Orca thinking that’s the finish line.”

Also, you will never pay off that Orca by mining. It will never happen.

I get it though. I’m an Orca pilot too. I have max skills in the Orca, drones, and mining and I even went so far as to reach a level 5 mastery of the ship. I tank the hell out of it and it sits as a fortress above my mining ship as it rips through the field.

But the Orca itself is useless without mining ships. Well, not useless… it’s the best and tankiest ore freighter in the game.

Yes.

That’s why it is a mining support ship.

It supports miners.

And it is really good at that role. Every miner would love to have your Orca next to them to provide 87% extra yield from cycle time reductions plus whatever extra yield they get from the crits you deliver, your remote compression so they can stay on grid, your remote repairs and support with drones, spare ships in your SMB etc etc.

The Orca is an incredible mining support ship and the driving force of many mining fleets, far superior in boosts, tank and storage capacity to the smaller alternatives the Outrider and Porpoise, only exceeded by the capital Rorqual which is limited to more dangerous parts of space.

Then don’t get an Orca.

You choose not to multibox, that’s fine.
You choose not to group up, that’s fine too.

Just don’t expect a ship that’s intended to be a huge group-buff to be useful to you then if you choose to fly in situations where it does not shine.

And yet, even then, the Orca is still decent as mining ship because of the huge storage capacity, massive tank and ability to simply mine for ages without much input.

Or get a smaller ship like a Mackinaw for more active mining if you wish to solo mine on your own with a single character.

Personally I recommend to join a group to mine, they’ll be very happy with your Orca even if you are not!

2 Likes

The Rorqual too is outperformed on ore by the Exhumers it boosts.

It has much stronger boosts though (and more risk too) than an Orca so it makes sense it also gets to risk bigger more expensive mining drones for more yield than a cheap Orca, so people have even bigger whales to hunt in space.

Why else do you think these mining support ship have names that so well fit whale hunts?

This isn’t a solo mining game.

The peak of solo mining is probably explo frigs, but I don’t mine so I don’t know or care.

Why not do something else in game?

I guess peak solo single character mining income may be an Odysseus with mining foreman bursts on an expensive gas site.

A huge risk though, a Venture or Prospect is a better idea.

Or a sieged Rorqual on ice, but you cannot really expect to fly one of those solo without other characters to support, defend and move you, or without a group to inevitably save you.

1 Like