Oh, absolutely; when, being the operative word. I had a friend from Tunisia attending Niceville High School (a real place not made up) who had to transfer to another school because the “adults” got involved on a matter that had already been resolved between two students.
She got into a discussion with another student from her region. The “death to America” phrase was used; but it was just young people stretching their wings, one crashing on their words and a peer straightening them out. The students did work it out, but the school still overreacted.
Words do matter and so does context and so very much does it matter how we regulate ourselves as a community. It’s nice to know young people from the Middle East can be just as smart and stupid as American kids. It is proof to me we are indeed all the same.
I am in a discussion right now on Quora about how reason gets run over by irrational behavior. I am getting comments from teachers and other professionals that are so very logical, but unsatisfactory to the issue of teaching students the whole truth and not just that reason conquers all, it does not. We are irrational creatures and not always civil.
As far as forums go I see why Quora has to have so many rules, but rules will never be enough. We need to be allowed to make mistakes. We need to feed the good wolf not just in ourselves, but in each other and not just beat the bad wolf. Have you seen the 2021 movie “The New Mutants”? The story actually talks about embracing our passion not fearing it. Knowledge is power, passion is powerful.
I have seen two incidents in EVE chats that might have been reportable as defamation, but the community took care of it in a civil and thoughtful manner. Most people are capable having the intelligence and the courage to not feed the beast, but rather to do the right thing. Often times it’s kinda like the commercial where what they really need is a Snicker’s bar.
I just heard a Moth Story where a man talked about the time he was tired and almost sent to jail for using vulgar language, or as Captain Kirk might say using colorful metaphors.
His kayak tuned over, he got angry and used some words he would not normally use around children. People nearby heard it, didn’t like it and the rest is recorded in some courthouse.
Sorry this is so long, but your comment is so
right on.
Hate & harassment are not words to be afraid
of either. Not talking about things is what we
should fear.