Multiboxing is a dishonest and lazy design. Dishonest, because the game presents itself as one pilot in one ship while selling the ability to be several, and because the online count overstates how many people are really in space. Lazy, because instead of designing a mechanic for controlling several ships, with rules, limits and counterplay, the game simply requires every extra account to be Omega and leaves the rest to subscriptions and hardware outside the game.
This is about the design, not the people who use it. It is unfair to both sides. Players who don’t multibox face advantages they can’t see or match. Players who do are pushed into paying for and managing extra accounts just to keep up, whether they enjoy it or not. For a lot of players it quietly kills the enjoyment.
I understand that a lot of the game assumes alts: cynos, scouts, haulers, boosters. So I don’t think a simple ban would work. My suggestion is to replace multiboxing with a designed mechanic, and close the old route at the same time. It has four parts.
- Clones on one account
Let one account control more than one clone at the same time.
- Each extra active clone is expensive to unlock and maintain, paid in ISK or PLEX.
- A new clone starts from zero skill points. It can be trained normally or with skill injectors.
- Fenris Creations sets the limits: how many clones per account, and possibly how many of one capsuleer’s clones can be on the same grid.
- Clones of the same capsuleer are visibly linked, so other players can see that three ships are one person.
For how it plays, think of Meepo from Dota 2.
- Control: all clones are managed from one client with an RTS-style interface (control groups, quick switching between ships), instead of several windows. Like Meepo, the clones only help if you can actually micro them, so the advantage depends on skill and not on how many screens you own.
- Linked fate: Meepo’s weakness is that if one of him dies, all of them die. Clones of one capsuleer share one mind, so they could be linked in a similar way. Losing any clone, anywhere in space, would hurt all the others: for example a neural shock that briefly disables them, a temporary penalty, or in the harshest version losing all of them. This gives a solo pilot a real play against a squad: find the weakest linked ship and kill it. It also means every extra clone you have in space is a risk, wherever it is.
- No more simultaneous accounts
From the day the update launches, playing separate accounts at the same time would no longer be allowed. Owning more than one account is still fine. The broadcast ban we have today is not enough, because EVE’s combat is slow enough to multibox by hand.
- Time to prepare before the update
People have put years and money into their alts, and they should not lose that. The update is announced well in advance, and players get a preparation period before it launches.
- During this period, an alt can be liquidated: its trained skills are turned into skill points. This is optional.
- The skill points are kept, and when the update launches they can be injected into the new clones, so veterans can rebuild their alts inside the clone system instead of starting over.
- Unused Omega time on alt accounts a player decides to close is refunded to the account they keep.
- Enforcement
A policy alone is not enough, so:
- Client lock: one running game session per machine, enforced by the launcher.
- Behavior analysis: accounts that are always online together and in the same system get a closer look. One person cannot act in two clients at the same moment, so their commands never overlap, while two real people overlap all the time.
- Human review and appeals before any penalty.
No system catches everyone, but if the legitimate route gives you several ships in one client with a proper interface, there is much less reason to cheat.
Why I think this is better than the current situation:
- It fits the lore. A capsuleer running several linked clones makes more sense than several “different” pilots who always move together.
- It becomes a mechanic that can be balanced, instead of a loophole that can only be tolerated.
- The advantage no longer depends on owning a stronger computer, and it comes with rules and a weakness.
- The player count would reflect real people again.
I know the obvious objections. It is a lot of new mechanics and would be hard to implement. Part of the community will not accept it. Extra accounts are a large part of the studio’s income, so clone pricing would have to replace that. And one person can still field several ships against a solo pilot. The difference is that it would be honest, visible, limited, and it would come with a weakness.
I expected this kind of reaction from the community but I wanted to be surprised.
Good luck finding new players.