No, he actually has a valid point. It could have been stated better though (key phrase being “do anything with”).
Compressed Ore currently loses value when converting it into minerals. The ore is worth more than the minerals it gets turned into.
justification provided here:
For the sake of “showing my work” Ore Value Actual Refined Units Compressed Price Compressed Volume Refined Value Gross Profit Margin Tritanium Pyerite Mexallon Isogen Nocxium Zydrine Megacyte Morphite Mercoxit $2,501,000.00 0.1 $3,302,400.00 32% - - - - - - - 258.00 Arkonor $497,400.00 8.8 $476,173.40 -4% 18,920.00 - 2,150.00 - - - 275.20 - Bistot $648,000.00 4.4 $525,021.40 -19% - 10,320.00 - - - 387.00 86.00 - Crokite $618,900.00 7.81 $471,537.14 -24% 1…
In responce to the OP though, I will say that the orca is well suited for its intended purpose (the transport of ore and moderate fitted ship hulls) It will function as an entry level freighter but once your cargohold value starts to exceed 500 million you need to start examining other more efficient options.