Crimson Harvest: Flawed room progression rewards parasites and steals players' real lifetime

Hello Fenris and community. I am writing this post to address a severe design flaw in the ongoing Crimson Harvest event (specifically regarding sites like the Tetrimon Base). The current room progression system actively rewards toxic, parasitic behavior while punishing players who actually engage with the PvE content.

This is not an isolated incident; it has become a widespread practice. Some players on expensive ships (like Marauders) choose not to actually play the game or complete the event challenges themselves. Instead, they wait and deliberately steal completed rooms from others.

Some might argue that “this is EVE, it’s about sandbox freedom.” But let’s look at the facts: these event sites already have strict rules and limitations implemented by design. You cannot access the second or third room without unlocking gates via keys or clearing NPC waves. The entry mechanics already restrict total freedom. So why do the rules protect the parasite who skips the work, but punish the player who clears the path?

When a player spends 30–40 minutes of their real-world time clearing the 1st and 2nd rooms in a standard ship, and an outsider simply slides into the 3rd room at the last second to steal the boss with superior Marauder DPS, it is not “emergent gameplay.” It is the theft of another player’s time and content. This is especially egregious in High-safety systems (High-sec), where the mechanics leave the victim with zero counterplay, as defending your own site results in instant destruction by CONCORD.

To make matters worse, the event rewards are already underwhelming and do not feel worth the immense effort. It feels like the team behind this event’s design is completely detached from the reality of how High-sec gameplay actually functions and how malicious players abuse these mechanics.

I have already raised this issue through player support. The GM team clarified that Customer Support has no tools to manually log or change gameplay design flaws and explicitly recommended sharing this feedback directly on the official forums so the development team can see it.

My proposals to fix this and future events:

  1. Lock the Progression Gates: Once a player (or fleet) activates and passes through an acceleration gate to the 2nd or 3rd room, that gate must lock completely for outsiders. If you didn’t do the hard work in the initial rooms, you should not be granted access to the finale.
  2. Introduce Gameplay Consequences (Suspect Timer): If a shortcut gate allows players to bypass rooms via a key, entering the final room while another player is already progressing through the standard path must have consequences. Anyone who intrudes into the 3rd room of an active site should automatically receive a Suspect/Criminal timer (turn red), allowing anyone to engage and destroy them without CONCORD intervention.

If EVE is about freedom, give us the freedom to legally defend our time and effort from parasites.

Thank you for reading, and I hope the development team reviews this feedback for future events.

2 Likes

I think part of EVE’s design is that such conflict between players naturally occurs, which then creates situations where players can attack each other, which is the content in this game.

Keys in these sites allow players to quickly bypass the dangerous first room and immediately go to the final room, while hunters get left behind unless they have their own keys to then catch the ship doing the final room.

Where this goes wrong is that it feels like people in HS play an entirely different game than the rest of us. Instead of simply attacking people for taking your site (or fleeing when you cannot take them), the HS mechanics introduce all this ‘stealing’ gameplay because players are all protected by threats of CONCORD.

There never should be an option to lock gates behind you.

This means ships become untouchable and invulnerable in space, which is a no-go in a PvP game. Ships should be reachable if they are in space, so let’s look for a different solution, like your next one.

I think a suspect timer is indeed the better way to go! This is purely a HS problem and suspect timers are the way to tweak the balance of interactions in HS space.

The goal would be to make the dynamics more equal to the intended gameplay like everywhere else in the game, so no more evil stealing protected by CONCORD but simple straightforward fighting over your loot.

I suggest anyone who enters the final room goes suspect, that should make it possible to deal with thieves yourself.

Exactly. Marauder pilots fly ships worth 1.5+ billion ISK. Right now, they only steal because they know they are 100% safe. If entering the final room triggered a Suspect timer, it wouldn’t just be about my Praxis fighting them. A Suspect flag in High-sec is a massive beacon for every ganker, combat scanner, and hunter in the region. These expensive Marauders would never risk their multi-billion ships for a single event loot container if it meant opening themselves up to legal PvP. The mere threat of a Suspect timer would stop this parasitism overnight.


Sargon really got to you, huh?

1 Like

It’s not about one specific player, but thanks for bringing up a perfect example. The fact that certain individuals can make an entire career out of purely parasitizing other people’s time in High-sec just proves my point completely.

When the game design creates an artificial safety net where someone can bypass all the actual content, steal the reward under CONCORD’s protection, and leave the person who did the 30-minute work completely helpless — that’s a mechanical flaw, not “emergent PvP”.

1 Like

Update:

I finally finished the reward track and opened the event’s “Grand Prize” container. You know, the one where the description hypes you up about a potential multi-billion ISK Molok Titan blueprint or the new Akoman battlecruiser.

Guess what I got? A single Cruor blueprint copy. A faction frigate BPC worth maybe 20 million ISK.

This is the perfect, live proof of what I said in my original post: the people who designed this event are completely detached from reality. You want players to use expensive Battleships, spend hours fighting off high-end Marauder parasites under CONCORD protection in High-sec, and the grand finale reward is a low-tier frigate blueprint that an average player can farm in 15 minutes of regular gameplay?

Expecting a Molok and getting a Cruor BPC after all that frustration is just a joke. This event is fundamentally broken — not just in its progression and gate mechanics, but in its reward tables as well. CCP, you really need to respect your players’ time.


1 Like

I received an Ashimmu Destroyer BPC…

Gotta say I’m not too thrilled about it, probably just sit in my ‘Invention and Production’ container…

But hey, it’s still a Pirate hull BPC…

DMC
o7

(something something) do them in low/nullsec because (something something) and you (something something and very much you something). :roll_eyes:

Just look at what CCP/FC does, not what they say. They don’t want people in Highsec, period. So if your intent is to keep playing PvE in Highsec in hopes that someday it will stop sucking, save your time and energy and stop giving them to FC right now. They don’t want you.

Win EVE and go play something else.

Exactly my point, DeMichael. (By the way, Ashimmu is a Cruiser, so you actually got slightly “luckier” than my Frigate BPC, haha!).

But jokes aside, this is precisely the issue. When veterans look at the “Grand Prize” of a major event and their reaction is just “well, I’m not thrilled, it’s probably going to sit in a container and rot,” it means the reward system is fundamentally flawed.

An event finale should feel rewarding and exciting, not leave players disappointed after weeks of effort and dealing with High-sec Marauder theft. Thanks for sharing your drop — it proves that this isn’t just one player complaining, but a design issue that affects everyone.

1 Like

Sad but true, Yiole. “Winning EVE” is starting to look like the only logical option here.

It really feels like CCP doesn’t want people in High-sec, but then why even create these events there in the first place? If their goal is to force everyone into Low/Null, making High-sec events a playground for protected parasites and rewarding hours of effort with a 20M frigate BPC is a terrible way to do it. It doesn’t motivate players to move to Null-sec; it just motivates them to close the game entirely.

If a game studio doesn’t want a huge portion of its player base to enjoy the content, then they shouldn’t be surprised when people actually follow your advice, save their time, and go play something else where their real lifetime is respected.

Thanks for the brutal honesty. Fly safe, if you’re still flying. o7

I won EVE in 2017 because one can only bang your head on a wall so much. Since I’m pretty much progression-motivated, I’m playing War Thunder, which is an actual PvP game made by a competent company whose numbers dwarf FC (220,000 players online during events, never less than 120,000) and unironically it’s been cheaper to play WT with premium account and the occasional splurging in a Premium vehicle than playing EVE Online ever was. More bang for less buck, 8,000+ hours and going.

And barely any drama, which also is a plus. Gaijin is not perfect but at least they KNOW who is paying their bills and make life easier to the mediocre masses, something CCP lost sight of after Incarnagedon and the CCP Seagull scourge with her plan to anything but Highsec PvE which succeeded to drive home the message that we (about 40% of the population) were unwanted.

I am not stupid. I know CCP is in a hard place and they can’t make highsec too profitable otherwise the game will stall, and I know that just adding new missions would only last a few years and eventually new mechanics would be needed, and I know that Walking in Stations was a dubious gameplay proposition unless it was tied to heavy cosmetics which would clash with “EVE is tough” mythos, but come on: if people are paying you to grind NPCs and put a new skirt on their avatar and show it off going to the local tavern, that’s what FF XIV has been thriving on for 13 years and counting. Same if they pay for shooting people in the face with a slightly different tank as in War Thunder for 14 years and going. You just need competent developers and a competent leadership to give them more of the same they pay for. But with EVE Online being the only pony of one-trick pony CCP, they’re bound to stick to what little is left of their player base until the last Goons quit and seal the fate of EVE Online.

Because nobody pays to always lose in PvP, and FC does their darnedest to ensure nobody succeeds doing anything else.

I see what you write.

I see the problem.

I do not think the problem is with the design of the event, however.

First, the crate in question goes for 3-4.4 billion ISK in Jita at the moment.


Evetycoon prices

Frankly, this is a massive guaranteed ISK reward for any temporary event!

The thing is that the crate has random rewards, so you could choose to gamble to consume this valuable crate to maybe get that one Molok blueprint, in which case a much more likely reward is something that is not a Molok blueprint.

You chose to gamble “expecting a Molok” and lost a crate worth billions of ISK to get a cheap blueprint in return.

The problem is this:

  • your unreasonable expectation to expect a Molok when it’s clearly explained this chance is very low
  • blaming the event for not having a profitable reward when you yourself decided to gamble the profitable reward away

There’s nothing wrong with taking a gamble, but please don’t blame the game when you lose a gamble you chose to take.

4 Likes

Ah, the good old “the problem it’s you” General Discussion gambit… :popcorn:

No. The problem is he’s paying 20 a month to FC and FC gave him a unrewarding waste of time while rewarding a-holes through carelessness and bad design decisions.

And if he stops paying 20 a month to FC, guess who’s problem will it be then?

That person decided to gamble to open a crate worth 4 billion, which they worked hard for and which likely is practically empty and has a very low chance of having a lot of ISK.

They lost the gamble and then they complain they got nothing for their work.

That’s clearly a problem of the player who consciously took that gamble.

Gambling is fine if you are willing to also take the loss. If you don’t want to risk being without payout, just sell that crate to someone else who wishes to gamble.

1 Like

The thread is about boxes being stolen by a-holes and the only one he gets is a dud.

Surely it’s his problem to pay for this crap…

I already responded to the ‘boxes being stolen’ part which I agree is an issue.

The fact that the one he got ‘is a dud’ only happened by gambling with it, which by nature of gambling has the risk of being a dud. Gambling it was optional and he chose to take the risk of it being a dud instead of selling it for the 4 billion ISK these things go for.

And frankly 4 billion ISK is a good reward for such events.

Personally I wouldn’t want to waste 4 billion ISK on a gamble like this, and I think they would have been happier making the same choice.

1 Like

I see the market data, Gerard, and you’re technically right about the price. But you’re missing the main point of my frustration.

I didn’t spend two weeks running events and dealing with Marauder parasites just to become a market trader and flip unopened boxes in Jita. I ran the event to get an actual, rewarding gameplay experience and a proper final trophy for my efforts.

If the best tactical decision in an event is to NOT open the “Grand Prize” and instead sell a cat in a sack to someone else, then the event’s reward design is fundamentally broken. A grand prize should feel like a reward, not a lottery ticket that punishes you for engaging with it.

Lesson learned, though. Next time, I will definitely sell the cat along with the sack without second thoughts. But it doesn’t change the fact that CCP made a slot machine instead of a proper reward track, all while keeping the site gates completely unprotected from parasites.

1 Like

Thank you, Yiole. You voiced exactly what the “just sell it on the market” crowd constantly seems to forget.

When a subscriber pays real-world money and invests weeks of their life into a major event, they expect an actual, rewarding gameplay experience and a proper trophy at the finish line.

If the pinnacle of game design in 2026 is to reward players with a “cat in a sack” lottery box, where the best tactical decision is to not open your grand prize but instead sell the sack on the market to avoid being scammed by rng — then the design is fundamentally broken. A reward track should feel rewarding to complete, not feel like an auction simulator.

Next time, lessons learned, I will definitely sell the cat along with the sack without second thoughts. But Yiole is absolutely right: when design choices actively protect and reward parasites while turning the grand prize into a slot machine, players will simply stop paying and go play something else where their time is respected.


1 Like

Gerard, you are viewing this purely as an ISK-per-hour spreadsheet simulator, while completely ignoring actual player psychology and game design.

Imagine completing a massive, multi-week campaign in any other RPG game, defeating the final boss, being handed the “Grand Champion Chest” — and the community tells you: “Oh, don’t open it! Opening it is a mistake. Just sell the locked box to someone else, because the developers filled it with garbage 99% of the time.”

Does that sound like a healthy, fun game loop to you?

Yes, it was my choice to open it. But when a game developer builds a major event reward track where the only “correct” and logical player behavior is to not engage with the reward and treat it like an auction commodity just to avoid being insulted by a frigate BPC, that is the definition of bad reward design.

I hear you, and I think that rewarding players with what is essentially a gamble can feel disappointing indeed when players don’t realize they can sell the valuable ticket, or don’t want to sell the valuable ticket and in the end get nothing for their efforts.

On the other hand this gamble is the only way CCP can do an event like this and hand out (a chance at) a free pirate titan!

Like wouldn’t it be awesome to give players a free BLOOD RAIDER TITAN in a blood raider themed event?

Of course CCP cannot simply hand out titans, so instead they hand out a blueprint copy, and a very very small chance at that blueprint copy at that. But someone is still going to get that titan bpc!

From a design point of view it’s a pretty awesome idea. And from the gamblers point of view it’s also fun, if I had plenty of ISK I’d probably roll my own ticket as well to see if I got a free titan!

So no, I’m not purely looking at it from an ISK-per-hour point of view, but I see it from multiple angles including the design of the event. And I think it’s pretty awesome to hand out a pirate titan as part of a pirate titan event!

I’m merely explaining it from an ISK-per-hour perspective because that is the part you were having issues with: you complained that the ISK for all that effort was wasted, after you decided to gamble with the end reward.

I’ll also share my own perspective on the event, which has not been mentioned yet. I dislike time-limited events and dislike the manipulative dark patterns that push players to complete tracks ‘in time’. I never liked them, but thse days as a dad with two young kids I barely have any time to play so such events go wasted on me. If you ask me such events also should be fun and engaging for people who don’t have lots of time to complete the track.

But instead I just skip this kind of content and simply play the game as usual as if there is no event whenever I see a chance to play.

1 Like