Personally I see the current structure and methodology of the CSM as more of a glaring sign of ‘what’s wrong at CCP and why they keep making EVE worse instead of better’.
Not disparaging any of the CSM members or CCPs staff, I am sure they are all doing the best they can with what they have access to.
It’s just that it’s basically, IMO, the same as saying “The government of your country has decided that the best way to represent the interests of all the people is to form an advisory committee made up of the tobacco industry, the oil industry, the fast food industry, and the banking sector. We feel confident that in this way the interests of all the people will be represented, and the economy won’t end up wildly distorted at all.”
I also feel that having the most game-breaking alliance consistently form over half of the CSM due to having in effect a majority voting block, is again, unlikely to be good for the overall long term health of the game.