HUD Feedback Thread!

I like the lines.

2 Likes

I think I get what you are saying, I am not going to make this animated but something like a pulsating halo effect.

Just Mad GIMP Skillz. lol

2 Likes

They don’t comment because they won’t bother reading. I feel like we are shouting into the wind here.

3 Likes

Hi folks.

I have a ton of feedback about the new HUD. Like that there’s far too much dead space in between the modules, and it uses too much overall space for the amount of info it contains, with buttons that are too small. But I also recognize that it’s a work in progress, and you’re getting a lot of that from other people on this forum and elsewhere.

BUT I’d like to most importantly get in and say please talk to people about getting colour-blindness accessibility right from the start. This is not a nice-to-have afterwards, it’s a thing that makes it possible for people to play or not.

For example, I overheated modules without even realizing it three times tonight. That’s not fun.

I am always happy to chat about this. As, I’m sure, are many others.

Thank you.

Farwin

4 Likes
  1. I hope the new HUD take up about the same amount of space as before. (see the figure below)

  2. I’d like there to be an option to turn off the sound effects of HUD.

2 Likes

Took me about 5 seconds in Duck AI.
Is this what you mean?



Love the idea.

Have fun!

At least gloss over it. They are dumping our old reliable HUD, I have sent out requests they allow us to choose, but they have opt-in running now, then opt-out later, and no choice as the final.

I ran this idea 2 ways by Duck AI and it spit out this;

or this;

I don’t care for either, I say leave the old HUD alone and available forever.

Have fun!

6 Likes

New HUD is TOO WIDE

There is no need for the new HUD to use so much space as it does. It is much wider than the old one.

Screen space is valuable, please don’t waste it.

I suspect that whoever develops this HUD has not tried placing it in between all the windows essential for combat on a 1920x1080 screen.

Or, an easier test is to pick the current HUD as your target size and reduce wasted space until the new HUD fits within the same amount of space:

  • reduce wide empty spacing between module buttons
  • reduce size of the compass. (It uses more space to show less information)
9 Likes

Please bring back the tactical overview button, it is very annoying to be forced to use menu when you want to switch it.

4 Likes

it appears the “sensor overlay” is gone and not acessable, wich was the only way to work around the bookmark bug by enable and disable it to make bookmarks in space visible again, and idea how this can be done with the new HUD?

Ctrl+O

2 Likes

HUD hitpoint readability test:

Can you tell at a glance?

No?

Me neither.

Our hitpoint bars have one primary function: to quickly show us our hitpoints at a glance.

The purpose is not to look novel, to look pretty or to show us info about our ship fit, it should show us the state of our ship.

Stacked bars make this less readable, proportionality adds inconsistency on top of that and the result is an fancy-looking ambiguous unclear mess.

This is unacceptable, please reconsider.

A suggestion:

20 Likes

It’s a good example but pretty deceptive. That armor or hull damage isn’t going to sneak past your shield/armor like that and confuse you in the heat of battle. Still, they could improve things with different colors or more prominent breaks.

Are you saying people cannot repair their armor in battle?

The only deceptive thing is the new HUD hitpoints.

More colours and shapes is not going to fix an inherently flawed design, it only reduces readability further.

What we need is three separate bars each in a consistent place.

2 Likes

Bad faith question. Worse than I expected from you. I am saying that you’re flying the ship and you can see your shield deplete, then your armor, then your hull. You will never have a case where a chuck of your hull disappears while you still have significant armor and shield. If you’re trying to make an argument about damage overpowering logi in a tick, then the new HUD does better because both movements are animated.

You must have missed the reason I asked that question.

People can repair their armor layer in combat.

Having your armor shoot up and down in combat is real in an actively tanked armor ship. Some damage bypassing armor to hull so you have a repaired armor layer and hull damaged is a real scenario.

While armor tanking I watch my armor and want to see when I need to repair it.

The new HUD makes it really hard to read your hitpoints at a glance when armor starts and ends at places inconsistent for each of your ships depending on which modules you have, which command links are applied and even which modules burned out.

This is why I think the new HUD is less readable than the old one.

5 Likes

I have been in some fights where my self healing shields repair. There are these mods we use called Armor Repair Modules, you might want to fit those sometime. They keep me from exploding, and the only thing I don’t use is the nanite paste for the hull. But I still know about it.

Gerard is not being deceptive, those are legit displays.

Have fun!

3 Likes

You missed this part:

If you’re trying to make an argument about damage overpowering logi in a tick, then the new HUD does better because both movements are animated.

Let’s be charitable and say you’re just being funny though.

not a bad faith Question, you’re the bad actor in this, lots of people giving feedback, justly.

Just not you.

2 Likes

Feel free to read my posts with both positive and negative feedback. Personal attacks are not welcomed though.