HUD Feedback Thread!

IDC, you’re opinion is a good reason why FCCP does not fix issues or listen to player feedback, so done talking to this Character, will just mute you, bye

I don’t PvP with logi etc. I have no idea how they work.

If I was in an abyssal with the new HUD, I need to know, to hit shield boost or the armor repair. Selecting the wrong one would be a lethal mistake. Maybe some of the players think we are just stick in the mud. The HUD is the last thing on the whole UI that needs any attention, yet here we are bickering with each other. The devs are like monkeys tossing raw meat to us dogs and watching us fight each other. They sure are not here giving out any sound advice, input, or praise for good ideas.

Have fun!

2 Likes

Overheat Comparison:


The first picture screams into my ears and eyes that stuff is hitting the fan and I should calm down a bit with the speed and tank.

The second swallowed the chill-pill and tells me nothing’s happening. IT does not at all convey the severity of my overheating status and how close to blowing-out my modules are. I even have a hard time to see the heat level indicator, let alone the damage amount already accrued because I do not clearly see where it ends.

In the heat of the battle when I have everything overheated, I SHOULD NOT be required to put the Windows microscope over the HUD to see where my heat stands. The HUD has to support me in such a fight, not collaborate with the enemy and sabotage me from within.

12 Likes

The key is “the heat of battle” - which is when tank changes can easily sneak past. Watching the overview, trying to prioritize and lock targets, switching weapons/modules on and off, changing ammo and watching cycle timers, managing capacitor, managing your distance/trajectory, watching who is in local, etc… which is why I think @Gerard_Amatin said “at a glance” because lots of things might happen fast / simultaneously which divides a players attention.

I have seen both cases Gerard illustrated happen ingame in the past numerous times. Which is why I’m not a fan of the new HUD yet - the new HUD requires me to focus on it more than I would like.

I’m hoping (but not holding my breath) that FCCP will take some of the player feedback and work on improvements on the HUD… Otherwise I might end up looking like this, trying to keep an eye on the overview, local, modules and the tank at the same time:

4 Likes

Sven Bauer did it like this:

3 Likes

The UI and UX of EVE Online are things I focus heavily on, so when a new HUD was announced, I was excited. And while the new HUD is a step in a good direction, in its current state it falls short. I understand this is a WIP and many elements are likely to change and evolve.
My initial impression is that this looks more designed for a mobile game than a PC game. FC have done an amazing job with graphics updates in EVE that make the game look amazing, only to have the game hidden behind windows, menus and controls that look dated. Photon UI definitely was an improvement, but still feels like its from the 2000s-2010s.
The new HUD is flat and bland. EVE is based in YC128, where capsuleers control their ships with neural connections and (as per the cinematics) using fluid, holographic, touch-screen panels. (aka; Ironman/After Effects). The think the new HUD (and UI) should follow that same design aesthetic.
I have been playing EVE since 2010. I have an Advanced Diploma in Graphic Design, I have an understanding in User Centered Design through a Bachelor of Psychology, and know sound very well as a musician with a Diploma of Music Production. While not an expert or authority in any sense, my feedback and suggestions come from more than just personal opinion and bias.
Some keywords and phrases that FC needs to keep in mind;
“Consistency” “Subtlety” “Functionality” and above all, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”.
What FC should have done first is a visual graphics update of the HUD, keeping everything in it’s original position, and only then begin to move things around based on user needs, functionality and usability. There was no immediate need to move everything around other than “we need something new”. I personally would like to know what the user and design requirements were for the new HUD.

Here is my initial feedback and suggestions;

GRAPHIC DESIGN

  • The spacing is obviously too much (which has been stated by many). The old HUD had a module spacing of 7px compared to the 11px of the new HUD, and the medallion and S/A/H readouts have too much wasted space (the old HUD also had wasted space that could have been utilised).

  • The overheat bars covering the bottom of the modules is ugly.

  • The entire module image glowing and huge countdown numbers looks cheap.

  • The ring around modules should be the key to information about the modules state and activity. Keep the cycle, reload, overheat and activation state all on that ring.

  • The capacitor recharge/drain indicator is amazing and needs to be emphasized.

  • I’m a fan of the new S/A/H indicators in theory, although I think there should be an option to choose between “dynamic” and “standard” layouts. The dynamic layout could continue using the top area. Again, there is no need to move things around unless there is a specific need to do so. The thickness does need to be dialed back and made visually smoother (pixelation on edges).

  • Autopilot button needs to be bigger!

  • Increase the size of the medallion or make use of the space around it. Maybe even the brightness could dim as the cap depletes?

Here are some simple mock-ups showing possible alternative layouts. (1 is old HUD, 2 is new HUD)

USABILITY

  • What happened to the radial menu? It was a huge hype. It’s something that exists within the game and is used by many. That functionality should remain throughout. Consistency.

  • Expanding side-bars and menus have become popular in many windows, why not keep that trend going? The HUD needs to be thought of as a fluid, interactive panel. Not a selection of dials and switches. Overheat controls and utility panels could expand from behind the central indicator when hovering over with the mouse.

  • The speed bar, while looking cool is again something that doesn’t need to relocate just for the sake of it. I also think the idea of the bar going orange/red during overheat could be cool.

  • The separation of utility buttons to both the left and right side of the HUD just makes no sense. Keep things together. Do not move it for the sake of it. The scanner buttons need to go back to the left. And go back to a radial menu. The hovering bulge looks like it’s designed for Android and Apple users.

  • The safety settings have nothing to do with scanners. Why are they linked? And why the small meaningless animation when you click on it?

  • The overheat controls seem too bulky and the extra click, while believing its to prevent accidental OH, feels pointless. The OH menu could sit in a panel that expands outwards to show more information and become interactive.

  • The order of the camera and T3 mode buttons needs to be addressed.

  • The tactical overlay should have a button. Veteran players know the keyboard shortcuts, but there should be an obvious fall-back option (unless FC want to permanently fix the TO to the TC?).

  • The compass and sensor overlay ring was nice, it gave a sense of the environment. Bring it back.

SOUND

  • The module on/off sound is clunky and sounds old. It needs to sound more subtle and electronic. It should resemble a haptic, a low-mid range buzz with a digital high-end element. Also multiple modules turning off simultaneously stacks and is much louder.

  • Are the module sounds designed to represent the sound of the actual module, or just the interaction with the button? The latter makes more sense, which would imply consistent sounds across all modules, but I do like some variation based on module group/category.

I have also uploaded a video covering the new HUD.
NEW HUD - First Impressions

4 Likes

If this is not a viable solution for FC because they insist to have proportionality of raw hitpoints visible in the hitpoint window, then I have two alternative solutions which do not create big readability issues:


Relatively more segments if you have more hitpoints, like capacitor.


Thicker bars for thicker tank layers.

10 Likes

I said this before and im saying it again, but what about just simple horizontal / vertical bars of health? no curves. and have numbers on it too.

will try to add a picture, but it will be a very bad looking picture.

3 Likes

I’ll take simple horizontal or vertical bars of health over the new HUD!
Just don’t stack them but keep them separate for quick reliable reading.

3 Likes

I hope this is not the next version of the curved proportional HP indicators for the HUD… :rofl: :melting_face:

10 Likes

Ok, for how simple the “thicker bars” suggestion is - it’s pretty darn effective at fulfilling the stated goal of dynamic HP bars, while avoiding the all the “readability at a glance” of the current iteration of the new HUD.

4 Likes

I best not reply then.

1 Like

My first look and review!

I try out the experimental HUD and a Guristas 4/10 site.
There are a some very good elements, and other parts need a whole lot of work or a total redesign.

Pros: Dscan accessibility, module activation feedback, vertical speedometer, heat rack highlight when hovering, color personalization, resists shown when hovering, better settings menu.

Cons: Illegible speed values, non smooth speed changes, dead space in the HP and capacitor wheels, less precise heat damage and HP readings, smaller angular size of HP bars, smaller clickable module area, no sensor overlay, defective capacitor delta indicator, larger total screen area requirement, no drugs in the module area yet.

Final score: 4/10, just like the DED site.

Yeah I did notice when typing in chat when I hit shift my hud lit up and I thought I got smartbombed. Gave me a heart attack.

The New HUD was quite literally made NOT to be like the old one, and there’s a whole explanation of it too.

I strongly dislike the new hud, other than the cap regen indicator.

I think it is worse in every way and I would always choose the existing HUD over this new one.

Same story as the ship info screen, which continues to be worse in every way.

4 Likes

What’s the explanation of displaying our health in a completely different manner to our locked targets’ health? Is there some advantage in having to explain to new players two completely different designs?

4 Likes

There isn’t one.

2 Likes

Evolution, not revolution | EVE Online

it ■■■■■■■ sucks like all other new ui, your ui team does not deserve to be employed

3 Likes