Well, then…
How about (Decoy ships) as a class?
Ships designed to imitate there regular counterparts (Like the Q-Ship) But with absolutely no weapons at all and a sh*t ton of armor, hull reinforcement and shields, with false signatures and decoy cargo generators?
Would that be a good compromise for you?
Heck Q-Ships could still be implemented, but the Freighter variants could be banned from High sec.
Even though that would partially defeat the purpose of why the Q-Ships would be implemented.
To trick gankers into wasting time and ISK on what they think will be un escorted, easy prey.
" It might do better in null and lowsec, but supply lines are already better guarded there."
That is a little weird… When you think about it.