I frequently hear stories of producers, studios, publishers and the like meddling with the creative process in an attempt to increase profitability. And, of course, we can all probably think of a hundred games off the top of our heads that had blatantly anti-consumer monetization methods or were lazy cash grabs.
So, yeah, I think it’s pretty safe to assume that there are people at CCP and PA that couldn’t give a rat’s ass about creative vision, fun and engaging gameplay, and doing right by their customers. In fact, we can probably see their influence coming through with things like in game ads and selling SP directly to players. However, that doesn’t mean that CCP has gone finger-tenting evil on us either. As I’ve been arguing in this thread, and across many others, there is no evidence that CCP introduced Resource Scarcity in order to sell plex, and there is plenty of evidence that indicates that unsustainable economic activity has indeed been going on. In fact, in the case of capital proliferation, players have even been asking CCP to deal with it. Thus, there is currently no reason to assume that CCP’s motivations are anything other than what they said they were.
There was I time when I couldn’t care less if other people believed in conspiracy theories, propaganda, and other misinformation. I viewed them with an amused curiosity, laughed at the memes, and went on with my life. That changed, however, after I made a outrage video about Eve in which I proposed my own little conspiracy theory. Now, I may have been a bitter vet, but I wasn’t trying to convince players to quit or sabotage the game. Unfortunately, that is exactly what I ended up doing, and I was alarmed when people in the comments said that they were quitting because of me. Of course I felt like an ass, but the experience also made two things salient to me: (1) morale is contagious, and (2) misinformation can have real consequences (I’ll avoid getting into recent real life examples).
So, you’re right. I do have a problem with conspiracy theories, as I think they can do real damage to player morale and retention. And this particular conspiracy theory bothers me more than most because it bears a striking resemblance to the one I released into the wild a few years ago. You might think that I have delusions of being more influential than I really am, especially since I’m not a particularly successful youtuber, but I do know that ideas, information, and misinformation can all sometimes have some serious legs. Naturally, I can’t help but wonder if my own conspiracy theory planted the seed for the one that’s growing today. And yes, the thought of that does bother me. In fact, that’s probably a contributing factor as to why I can get so combative about it.
Anyway, I thought about linking my outrage video, but decided against it (if anyone really wants to see it, they can probably find it). But I’m not sure I want to risk it adding more fuel to the fire. So instead, I’ll just link a screenshot of my script (yes I make glorified powerpoint presentations).
TLDR: I have a problem with conspiracy theories because misinformation can cause real harm (such as damaging player retention and morale). And I have a big problem with this particular conspiracy theory because I may very well be the douche bag who started it.
Sorry for the long post. Here’s a tangentially related video. It’s about director cuts, but it also talks about the push and pull between creative types and money men.