Okay, let’s get real here.
Yes, the forums have plenty of whiners, but most of them are infrequent posters. Some come out just to complain in the dev blogs, and those that make threads or post in other people’s threads tend to catch plenty of ■■■■ from many of the regulars. I mean, I’ve seen whiny posts collect lots up upvotes in dev blogs, but I’ve also seen people like Noori Nari (spelling) get torn to pieces in their whine threads.
Second, Reddit certainly has it’s fair share of whiny bitter vets. If you need citations, just let me know.
Third, at least half of the “players that know what they are talking about,” don’t actually know ■■■■. Just like in real life, many players are surprisingly bereft of original thought, and just regurgitate up the thoughts of others. And, I’m pretty damn sure that the problem is even worse on Reddit -which brings me to my next point…
While ehco chambers have popped up in all corners of the internet, the particular voting mechanics on reddit are especially detrimental to debate, which engenders groupthink. Even Reddit seems to be aware of this fact, which is why they started hiding votes on recently posted comments. Unfortunately, however, they still haven’t addressed the burying of dissenting opinions through downvotes.
All social media platforms have their advantages and disadvantages, and the Eve forums are no exception. But, I chose to use the forums over reddit because you can’t just silence people you disagree with downvotes. If someone says something you disagree with, you actually have to make a compelling argument as to why you think they’re wrong, or you’ll fail to persuade anyone.
Either that, or I’m a whiny idiot who can’t hack it on Reddit. One of the two.