I’m a bit more diplomatic than that, but the sentiment that this is extremely gameable and may not result in the kinds of behavior they expect has been fundamental to my response to it.
The question of whether it impacts me and my allies or some other group is immaterial - my job isn’t to do what’s in the best interests of my group, it’s to do what’s in the best interests of the game. I agree that some kind of resource depletion for overfarmed areas is needed, the issue for me has always been in the implementation so that it’s not easily gamed.