Maybe the Blackout would have been more accepted if it was more balanced.
Before it happens, the situation was like that for both sides.
- Tools for PVPers to find targets : the filters of the ingame map or the externals websites like Dotlan, Zkillboard (for knowing PVEers fits), cloaked ships, Dscan, Local to see if there is a target.
- Tools for PVEers to avoid being killed : Dscan, social interactions (intel channels), Supercap Umbrella if available, Local (most efficient for them).
Zkillboard and the ingame map are too delayed and inadequate to be used by PVEers as an intel tool, apart for avoiding gatecamps. They permit to know populated areas and NPC farming sectors or even most jumped systems, so they are more interesting for PVP. Still, the Local is largely efficient for defense than for finding an easy target, so it is an essential tool for PVEers.
That means that with the Blackout, the PVEers was cleary at a disadvantage, and he was worse with time as people was leaving the game and so reduced even more the efficiency of the intel channels and of the Supercap Umbrella. And when CCP declared that the cynos was about to be nerfed, PVEers would lose one another tool (no need to be on standby in capital ships as jumping was made less efficient and more costly).
At the same time, PVPers using cloaked ships got more chances to kill targets easily. I lost a Gnosis this way despite having the Dscan opened and regularly refreshed.
So… Blackout + Cynonerf =
- Tools for PVPers to find targets : the filters of the ingame map or the externals websites like Dotlan, Zkillboard (for knowing PVEers fits), cloaked ships, Dscan
- Tools for PVEers to avoid being killed : Dscan
And some people seriously expected the PVEers to continue playing in this situation ?
So… If CCP removed (yes I meant removed, not delayed) the filters of the Ingame map and any ESI related endpoints (and so nerfed Dotlan) AT THE SAME TIME that they removed the Local, it would have been more balanced and so maybe more tolerated, because the PVPers would have to work to find targets instead of relying on the remaining free intel tools of the game, and our side would have to find ways to adapt.
The only answer was to “HTFU, PVEers”, and as the PVPers was crying because of the Supercap Umbrella, the Cynonerf was coming… So the PVEers decided to win EVE.
Next time, don’t remove intel of only ONE side. In skirmishes and war, both sides have them. So it is both sides without ANY intel, or both sides with decent intel. No side should be advantaged, or the other one will die.
And so we died. Most of the PVEers at least.