I voted no. Though the philos question remains - when does a new player not become a new player.
Eve has a small learning curve (I’m saying this in the scientifically accurate sense). It’s hard to learn the basics. I didn’t really start learning EVE until I became a part of COIM and could pick the brains of really experienced players.
I know the arguments about killing newbies is often linked to sociopathy and I argue the same. If you kill a weak target knowing you’ll loose your asset - it doesn’t do anyone any favors. I think shooting at newbies might be a good way to introduce them to EVE but why kill them. Or if you’re really that good why don’t you kill them in a lesser ship than they are flying - or fly a beginner ship poorly outfitted.
This is a game - true. But I think people who pray on new players are playing sociopathic characters. How would you know they are new? or where do you draw the line? Everything in Null Sec seems a go. Low sec should likewise be a go. However, why would you blow up people who are no threat to you, are not doing anything to impede you or your development or aren’t even worth your blowing them up.
Honestly - what are you going to do - scoop the recks of shuttles corvettes and frigates? I could see battling them in a corbette or frigate to actually challenge your bassic skills or prowess but that is combat for combats sake which is not primarily what killing newbies or ganking is about.
So gate camping in high sec to blow a industrial and have a buddy scoop the wreck. Why not. that makes sense to me. There is a benefit. industrial pilots should not be newbies.
It would be nice though it the pvp side of everything wasn’t sorta like - if you’re in a ship - we kill ya and that’s that.
Also, ganking miners? Yeah, that’s fine. But to systematically target specific miners or clear out whole mining fleets by gank to control a system seems really strange to me. Sure you can control the system or get scoop the wrecks but it doesn’t seem to be honorable - equivalently profitable or even difficult.
Maybe miners should be on their toes or if they aren’t paying attention maybe they should die. But targeting venture pilots in normal space seems lame. Why? It makes no logistical sense or financial sense and unless you want to control mining rights to the system there’s no real resource isk incentive for such behavior.
All in all, I don’t know why anyone should shoot down corvettes frigates or ventures just for the hell of it. Obviously if they are wh or relic or data site mining or even combating a site you had tagged - sure - but why kill a guy trying to go from point a - b.
I think - one of the most important things you can provide in your controlled space is safety and travel to benign pilots. But you kill everything and that just makes all of space rediculously dangerous all of the time in counterintuitive ways. It doesn’t mean EVE is like the real world. It means it’s like you get shot at or stabbed every time you leave your house to go to the grocery store even though your minding your own business.
I think people should have more tact. Maybe I’m a crybearing baby. Or maybe one day I’ll make it my mission to hunt and kill people who hunt and kill benign targets. Who knows. Right now? I like to mine.